Skip to content

Idler

  • Idle Thoughts
  • Retreats
  • Academy
  • Shop
  • Events
    • Events
    • Idler Festival
    • Calendar
  • About
    • About Us
    • FAQ and Knowledge Base
    • Where to buy
    • Sample Issue
    • Patrons
  • Login
    • My Online Courses
    • Audio
    • Video
    • Digital Edition
    • My Details
    • My Orders
  • Subscribe
Get Free Newsletter

Whole Lotta Love

Georgia Mann | 9 Apr 2026 | Idler Magazine

King David surrounded by troubadours, from the Olomouc Bible, 1417

The aristocratic troubadours of medieval France taught Led Zeppelin how to find the stairway to heaven, says Georgia Mann

As the 12th-century love story of Abelard and Heloise is being explored elsewhere in this edition of the Idler, I’m going to jump on the medieval bandwagon and look at how the troubadours of that bygone era gifted us the modern-day love song. Writing tunes about aphrodisiacs and seductions, the trobairitz (female aristocratic poet-composers) and wandering minstrels of the age blurred the sacred and the secular, leaving a legacy that has affected everyone from Wagner (more on which later) to Led Zeppelin, with songs such as “The Battle of Evermore” channeling knightly themes.

The notion of musical creation is bound up in the very word troubadour. The term comes from the Occitan verb trobar, meaning “to find” or “to compose”. The troubadours emerged in the late 11th century in Occitania, a region that encompassed Aquitaine and cities like Carcassonne, Bordeaux, Limoges, and Poitiers. These medieval singer-songwriters were breaking with tradition by opting to sing not in Latin, as was the norm, but in Occitan, the vernacular language of southern France. These weren’t songs about war or heroic exploits either. For the first time since the likes of Ovid, bards were now waxing lyrical about love, and they were doing it in a language everyone could understand.

As someone who struggled through the medieval poem Le Roman de la Rose (The Romance of the Rose) as an undergraduate, I’m not well placed to elucidate on the concept of courtly love. My main takeaway from tedious hours spent conjecturing about what the hell Guillaume de Lorris was on about, is that his extended allegorical dream in pursuit of a rose represented the torturous idea of female sexuality as something to be desired, pursued, but perhaps always best kept at a safe distance. That was also what many a troubadour was singing about; the unobtainable, but wildly desirable, lady fair.

Just how raunchy did a troubadour track get? Well of course they vary. One song imagines slipping a lady’s slipper off her foot, while a song by troubadour Guilhem de Peiteu is about how he can’t wait to get his hands under his lady’s cloak. Hip hop has become notorious for raps about turbo-charged promiscuity and the aforementioned Led Zeppelin were no slouches when it came to notches on bed posts – but could they top Guilhem’s claim to having a “chamber of joy” with 184 women for his pleasure?

I’m a big fan of the music historian Ted Gioia, who has said he believes “music is a force of transformation and empowerment, a catalyst in human life”. The troubadours were catalysts; they helped to transpose the sacred into the secular when it came to medieval music-making. Gioia explains: “Because the troubadours often sang about sex, many have assumed they had frequent love affairs. But this misunderstands the complex relationship between Christianity and the troubadour ethos, which are interlinked at every stage. Certainly there were seductions and indiscretions, but more often the troubadours preferred to sing about an unobtainable lady – for example, the wife of a noble – because this allowed them to express the most passionate feelings in a manner that was still compatible with the dictates of chastity … It’s hardly a coincidence that the cult of the Virgin Mary was at its height in European life during this same period. The secular and sacred often blur together in this music.”

So, who were the troubadours? To borrow some hip-hop terminology, the Original Gangster troubadour was the aforementioned Guilhem de Peiteu (1071-1127). He was the duke of Aquitaine, and kept court at Poitiers, so was the noblest of the troubadour tribe. Guilhem was a soldier as well as a poet, and went on the Crusade of 1101, most likely bringing Arabic influences back with him.

Not all troubadours were men; there were 20 noted female trobairitz. They came from noble families, but their songs diverged from their male counterparts in a major way. While the boys were full of highfalutin ideas of courtly love, the girls were altogether more direct. Meg Bogin, author of The Woman Troubadours, says of them: “The voices of the women troubadours are as complicated as the voices of real people, and as Earth-bound. They sound like women any of us could know. Unlike the men, who often wrote in the persona of the knight, the women wrote in no one’s character but their own.”

It’s impossible to over emphasise the importance of the trobairitz. They occupy a very special place in musical history as the first known female composers of Western secular music; all earlier female composers wrote sacred stuff. As Annie Lennox would later sing, these sisters were “doin it for themselves”.

The triple whammy of the Albigensian Crusade, The Hundred Years War and the Black Death helped bring the troubadourian party to a close. By that point, those proto-love songs had crossed borders. Dante Alighieri wrote about troubadour lyrics in his essay “On Eloquence in the Vernacular”; and the similar, 13th-century tradition of Minnesang developed in Germany, feeding directly into Wagner’s plot for Tannhauser, which is all about the lives and art of the lyrical minnesingers. So, next time you hear a Wagner aria or “Stairway to Heaven”, spare a thought for those 12th-century pioneers and their game-changing songs of seduction.

Georgia recommends Trouvères et Troubadours: Aux Origines de la Chanson from Ensemble Obsidienne (Bayard Musique).

This article is from Idler #109 May/June 2026 – out now.


Subscribers may comment. Please add your idle thoughts using the box below

Subscribe to the Idler here and get 12% off the shop price plus a FREE copy of Idle Thoughts by Tom Hodgkinson, worth £8.95.


How to Live Like a Stoic

Tom Hodgkinson’s latest book How to Live Like a Stoic: A Handbook for Happiness (Bloomsbury Continuum, £16.99) is out now. Order a copy via Linktree here.


The May/June 2026 issue of the Idler (#109) is available in Waitrose, Smiths and TG Jones.

Click here for your nearest stockist.


Subscribe to the Idler here and get 12% off the cover price plus a free copy of Tom Hodgkinson’s latest book Idle Thoughts: Letters on Good Living.

Buy single issues here.

You must be logged in to view this article.

For unlimited site access, join us as a member here or login

Related Items

Subscribe to the Idler! 17% off cover price plus free copy of Idle Thoughts

Idler Magazine

Get the Idler magazine delivered to your door

Interview: Glenn Tilbrook

Tom Hodgkinson | Idler Magazine

Tom Hodgkinson speaks to the Squeeze frontman

Loitering in the Cloisters

Harry Mount | Idler Magazine

Harry Mount presents a history of cloisters

The Gardens of Florence

Victoria Hull | Retreat

Six days of great food, Renaissance art and stunning gardens

Picturesque Gardens to Visit

Tim Richardson | Travel

Tim Richardson highlights a trio of great gardens to explore

The Idler Gardens of Florence Retreat SOLD OUT

7 Sep 2026 | Retreat

Retreat to Florence and Chianti with the Idler and discover some of Italy’s most important landscape gardens hidden in this magical city and the countryside of Chianti around it.

Pilgrimage Retreat

Idler Pilgrimage Retreat

9 May 2026 | Event

Join us for a week of walks, talks and yoga on the Idler pilgrimage Retreat, following the footsteps of St Francis of Assisi through the glorious Umbrian countryside.

Spanish Retreat

Idler Spanish Retreat 2026

25 Apr 2026 | Retreat

Join the Idler Spanish Retreat and relax at a finca in a twelve hectare garden in the desert of southern Andalusia. Learn about flamenco and the literature and turbulent history of Andalusia, visit the oldest Moorish citadel in Spain, walk along the unspoilt Cabo de Gata coastline and practise yoga.

Carcassonne Retreat

Idler Carcassonne Retreat SOLD OUT

29 Sep 2026 | Retreat

In an eco manor house nestled in ancient woodland learn about the Cathars, the love and song of the Troubadours, and local cuisine with special guest Rowley Leigh

Egyptian Retreat

Idler Egyptian Retreat, November

16 Nov 2026 | Event

Join the Idler for a retreat to little travelled Middle Egypt as we explore the ancient Egyptian hermetic philosophy that has influenced Western thinkers from the Renaissance to today.

Academy Membership

Subscription

Unlimited access to 75+ online courses, six issues of print magazine, digital edition, back issue archive, audio channel and free tote

digital

Digital Membership

Subscription

Join us as a cyber-idler and get …

A year’s worth digital edition of

Digital Academy Gift

Digital Academy Gift Card

Gift

With the Digital Academy Gift Card you give a year’s membership of the Idler’s

Stick It Up Your Punter

Arthur Smith | Idler Magazine

Arthur Smith on the art of heckling and how to deal with it

Thought for Easter: Why Doubt Matters

Mark Vernon | Thought for the Week

Mark Vernon welcomes the doubting Thomases

Bread of Hope: The Ukrainian Easter Loaf

Julia Lasica | From the archives

A symbol of optimism for the future

A Tale of Two Storeys

Alex Johnson | Idler Magazine

Alex Johnson on the history of Charles Dickens’ writing shed

A Twist in Time

Alex Tait | Idler Magazine

Alex Tait visits an idle home with a split personality

The Story of the Grape-Gathering Hedgehog

Hugh Warwick | From the Archives

Hugh Warwick unravels a medieval myth

Solace of Quantum: A Chat with Carlo Rovelli

Carlo Rovelli | Archives

Physicist Carlo Rovelli talks science and philosophy with Tom Hodgkinson

Why I Hate Modern Cafés

Gustav Temple | Idler Magazine

Gustav Temple loved the greasy spoons

Print’s Not Dead

Tom Hodgkinson | Letter from the Editor

Enjoy the beauty of analogue with the Idler, says Tom Hodgkinson

Dad Still Plays a Mean Pinball

Tom Hodgkinson | Letter from the Editor

Tom Hodgkinson on the power of hitting the tables

Thought for the Week: On Why We Work

Mark Vernon | Thought for the Week

Mark Vernon on the ethical problem of the office job

Wine and Revolution

Josh Sutton | Essays

Marx was a wine-lover and two of his followers founded the Complete Imbiber

Ai on AI

Ai Weiwei | Idler Magazine

Ai Weiwei on artificial intelligence

Let’s Roll

Will Hodgkinson | Idler Magazine

Will Hodgkinson on the glory of pinball machines

The Power of Positive Drinking

Rachel Kelly | Idler Magazine

Rachel Kelly on the benefits of booze

  • Idler
  • About
  • Join the Idler
  • My Account
  • Calendar
  • Digital Edition
  • Audio Channel
  • Online Courses
  • Events & Talks
  • Newsletter Sign Up
  • ADVERTISE
  • FAQ and Knowledge Base
  • Sample Issue
  • Where to Buy the Idler
  • Buy Back Issues
  • Contact
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

Great Western Studios, 65 Alfred Road, London W2 5EU

©2026 The Idler

Idler Logo

Join the Idler's mailing list for free

“Tom’s newsletters offer me the chance to learn about everything that really matters and a respite from what we are told really matters – like working hard for your boss,”
Dominic West