Skip to content

Idler

  • Idle Thoughts
  • Retreats
  • Academy
  • Shop
  • Events
    • Events
    • Idler Festival
    • Calendar
  • About
    • About Us
    • FAQ and Knowledge Base
    • Where to buy
    • Sample Issue
    • Patrons
  • Login
    • My Online Courses
    • Audio
    • Video
    • Digital Edition
    • My Details
    • My Orders
  • Subscribe
Get Free Newsletter

Democracy and its discontents

Mark Vernon | 3 Jul 2016 | Sermons

Socrates

Democracy is dangerous. Just ask Boris. Just ask Jeremy Corbyn.

But we’ve been surprised at its power in the last week or so. Democracy is often given three unthinking cheers in liberal countries, not the two modest cheers E. M. Forster advised. Hence the referendum was originally welcomed as the pinnacle of democratic freedom: everyone’s vote counts. But maybe democracy’s power will make the poor poorer and plunge the UK into decades of existential crisis.

Or perhaps, longer term, it will prove wise: maybe we’ll be glad to be free of the vices of the EU and folly of the euro. Who knows. So crystal balls aside, what might the shock of our revolution remind us about the political system that we’re seeing so powerfully shape us?

There are dangers acknowledged from the first by its inventors, the ancient Athenians. Aristotle called democracy “the most friendly” constitution, when it works, though it was democracy that killed his mentor, Socrates, and caused him to flee Athens and die abroad when the people turned against him too.

The key element the Athenians stressed is that democracy is not about the individual, but the collective. The very word means power to the people – a collective noun – and people en masse routinely and readily become a frightening force. Think of the global leader with, I think, the biggest democratic mandate: Putin in Russia. And he could soon be set against Trump.

So the Athenians cultivated remedies to check the risks of group think. The most startling was ostracism. Every few years, a rising political star was sent into exile. They were cast out, no appeals allowed. It was a safeguard with twofold intent.

One was to protect the polis from demagogues, individuals who through force of rhetoric threatened to play the crowd and unleash its darker energies. Second, ostracism was to discourage demagogic designs: the ruthless threat of losing everything as deterrent.

It wasn’t a perfect solution. They don’t exist. Two cheers for democracy – though today, we’d feel it simply too harsh, unfair on Boris, even Farage. Perhaps that needs a rethink.

After all, ostracism was itself a democratic process. It wasn’t exercised at the whim of rulers, to get rid of unwanted opponents. It was an act of political responsibility. Better a vote than newspapers, who are sometimes said to do our ostracizing for us?

A second crucial containment of ancient democracy was the theatre, and the Dionysian festival of tragedies in particular. The heart-rending plays of Aeschylus and Sophocles, exposing the horrors of war, love and tyranny, were an astonishing exercise in self-perception. The opposite of spin and doggy dossiers, they were a collective exercise in emotional intelligence.

We still get a taste of them when, say, solemnly remembering the one million slaughtered in the Somme. One million. How many cheers for democracy?

Perhaps in our two cheers today, a possible improvement in our experiment, compared with our forebears’, might be highlighted. Universal education.

Research on groups suggests that when groups are diverse in terms of their opinions, and can tolerate sharing that diversity; when groups offer the kind of belonging that means members want to serve the others, as a team; and when groups are focused on wider interests, not just the self-interests of the group – then they can prove very smart indeed, becoming an intelligent collective that’s wiser than the brightest loner.

As people of the polis, what’s required is an education, in Plato’s sense – to build emotional intelligence: trust in life, comfort with oneself, recognition of limits.

And that last bit is key. Knowledge is not something we posses. It’s discovered. It’s not our property, but belongs to the gods. Fate always haunts us. Though, if we look, we’re also always offered glimpses of the good, the promise of hope. Here’s a cheer for that too.

You must be logged in to comment on this article.

For unlimited site access, join us as a member here or login

Share: Facebook | X | Email


Idler Logo

Join the Idler's mailing list for free

“Tom’s newsletters offer me the chance to learn about everything that really matters and a respite from what we are told really matters – like working hard for your boss,”
Dominic West

Previous Article Back Next Article

Related Items

What the Tortoise Teaches Us

Andrew Quayle | Archives

“A tortoise is never euphoric nor miserable. It is stoically content”

Cartoon by Modern Toss

Modern Toss | Cartoon

Plus: release your inner cartoonist with the Idler Academy

Skateboarding Is not a Sport

Thom Callan-Riley | Idler Magazine

Thom Callan-Riley visits the Slow Impact weekender in Phoenix, Arizona

  • Idler
  • About
  • Join the Idler
  • My Account
  • Calendar
  • Digital Edition
  • Audio Channel
  • Online Courses
  • Events & Talks
  • Newsletter Sign Up
  • ADVERTISE
  • FAQ and Knowledge Base
  • Sample Issue
  • Where to Buy the Idler
  • Buy Back Issues
  • Contact
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

Great Western Studios, 65 Alfred Road, London W2 5EU

©2026 The Idler

Idler Logo

Join the Idler's mailing list for free

“Tom’s newsletters offer me the chance to learn about everything that really matters and a respite from what we are told really matters – like working hard for your boss,”
Dominic West